Surgery
-
Data were collected for 163 students completing a surgical clerkship including scores on patient write-ups, ward performance evaluations, oral examinations, and National Board of Medical Examiners (NBME) Surgery subscores. Oral examination scores and patient write-ups were rated from 74 (failing) to 100 (honors) by faculty members. The ward performance evaluation included ratings on nine components of ward performance from 1 (unsatisfactory) to 4 (superior) and an overall ward score of 74 (failing) to 100 (honors). ⋯ Although these results suggest that residents are better evaluators of a clerk's performance than are faculty members, other studies indicated the opposite. The elimination of participation of either faculty or residents in the grading of students is unwise. Periodic monitoring of evaluation practices is necessary to ensure fairness in grading procedures.