Medical hypotheses
-
The clinical assessment of sarcoidosis has been confounded by its inexact diagnostic criteria, multiorgan involvement, and effects of therapy. In this manuscript an instrument, the Sarcoidosis Three-Dimensional Assessment Instrument (STAI), is proposed to assess the clinical state of sarcoidosis. The instrument examines each organ involved with sarcoidosis separately. ⋯ Severity is based both on the decline from normal capacity as well as physical and psychosocial limitation. Disease activity takes into account changes in organ function as well as changes in therapy. Although this instrument is presently not validated, it is hoped that it will undergo study as it rationally accounts for several problems of previous assessment instruments.
-
Editorial
Mega-prizes in medicine: big cash awards may stimulate useful and rapid therapeutic innovation.
Following Horrobin's suggestion of 1986, I argue that offering very large prizes (tens of millions of US dollars, or more) for solving specific therapeutic problems, would be an excellent strategy for promoting the rapid development of effective new treatments. The two mainstream ways of paying for medical research are funding the process with grants or funding the outcome via patent protection. When grants are used to fund the process of research the result tends to be 'pure' science, guided by intrinsic scientific objectives. ⋯ For example, medical charities focused on specific diseases should consider accumulating their resources until they can offer a mega-prize for solving a clinical problem of special concern to their patients. Prize money should be big enough to pay for the research and development, the evaluation of the new treatment in a clinical trial, and with a large profit left-over to compensate for the intrinsic risk of competing. Sufficiently large amounts of money, and the prestige and publicity derived from winning a mega-prize, could rapidly mobilize research efforts to discover a whole range of scientifically un-glamorous but clinically-useful therapeutic breakthroughs.