Der Unfallchirurg
-
Comparative Study Clinical Trial Controlled Clinical Trial
[Fluoroscopy based surgical navitation vs. mechanical guidance system for percutaneous interventions. A controlled prospective study exemplified by distal locking of intramedullary nails].
The aim of this study was to directly compare mechanically based targetting and surgical navigation when applied for percutaneous osteosynthesis. The distal locking procedure of intramedullary nails was used as the clinical model for a controlled prospective study. A total of 50 patients were included in two groups. ⋯ There was no significant difference in the fluoroscopy time or in the number of intra-operative technical problems. Surgical navigation increased the demand for resources but failed to improve the precision of distal locking compared with mechanical guidance. Further clinical studies are required to determine to what degree these results, using a special model, relate to other applications.
-
Comparative Study Clinical Trial
[Iso-C(3D0-assisted) navigated implantation of pedicle screws in thoracic lumbar vertebrae].
The mobile Siremobil Iso-C(3D) C-arm (Siemens AG, Medical Solutions, Erlangen) is the first device that permits the intraoperative three-dimensional (3D) representation of bone structures. A high-resolution isotropic 3D data cube in the isocenter with an edge length of approximately 12 cm is calculated simultaneously. The Siremobil Iso-C(3D) is linked to navigation with the integrated NaviLink interface (Siemens AG, Medical Solutions, Erlangen). ⋯ Also the lowest average fluoroscopy time (1.28+/-0.56 min) was achieved during the placement of pedicle screws on the spine with Iso-C(3D) navigation at a comparable average OR duration (103.26+/-23.3 min). There were no postoperative neurological complications in all 30 patients. From these data we conclude that Iso-C(3D) navigation of pedicle screws is a very accurate method in the correct placement of pedicle screws.
-
The goal of these studies was to evaluate the accuracy of in vivo and in vitro application of CT- and C-arm-based navigation at the thoracic and lumbar spine. With CT based navigation, 82 pedicle screws were consecutively inserted, 53 into the thoracic and 29 into the lumbar spine. Seven (13%) perforations were detected at the thoracic spine and two (7%) at the lumbar spine. ⋯ For the C-arm based navigation the distance was 2.6 mm (0.9-4.8 mm) for the thoracic spine and 2 mm (1.2-3 mm) for the lumbar spine. In our opinion, the clinical results of the comparative accuracy of CT- and C-arm-based navigation in the present study showed moderate advantages of the CT-based technique in the thoracic spine, whereas CT- and C-arm based navigation had comparable perforation rates at the lumbar pedicle. The results of the experimental study correlated with the clinical data.
-
Comparative Study
[CT and fluoroscopy based navigation in pelvic surgery].
Navigation procedures based upon CT data were introduced into spine surgery in 1994. Since then the method has been used in other areas, such as joint replacement, reconstructive surgery and tumor surgery, because of its high precision and reduced radiation exposure. The original CT-based spine module can be adapted for pelvic surgery with the prerequisite, that the positioning of the fragments is identical in CT and at operation; otherwise, a new data set has to be acquired. ⋯ In one screw an anterior cortex perforation of the sacrum was seen on CT, but without neurological consequences. Based upon our clinical experience we believe that CT-based navigation is indicated in screw fixations for minimally displaced pelvic injuries or dysplasia and, with increasing importance, in tumor surgery. Fluoroscopy based navigation with adequate image quality is the method of choice for SI screw fixations in traumatic or degenerative instabilities, especially if an update of the images is needed.