British journal of anaesthesia
-
Editorial Comment
Spinal GABAA receptors for pain control: back to the future?
-
Why is this important?
Suspicions that anesthetic technique impacts survival after cancer surgery continues to be both unanswered and psychologically weighty: are anesthetic choices undermining patient survival?
What did they do?
This Taiwanese research group conducted a retrospective cohort-study in a single hospital covering 10 years of elective hepatectomy patients, comparing propofol to desflurane anesthesia. Notably, hepatocellular carcinoma is one of the leading causes of cancer death in Taiwan.
And they found...?
TIVA propofol was associated with a dramatically better survival (hazard ratio 0.57 (0.38-0.59)), even in subgroup analysis dependent on staging.
Reality check
Although this finding is consistent with other observational studies across a range of cancers, the apparent size of the benefit (50% mortality reduction!) should give us pause.
Given inconsistent findings from a range of similar observational studies, it is unlikely that there is a real treatment effect of this magnitude.
While we await results from well-powered RCTs, the jury is still out on whether anesthesia choices impact any specific cancer surgery...
summary