Encephale
-
Review Comparative Study
[Antidepressants and their onset of action: a major clinical, methodological and pronostical issue].
Although antidepressant medications are effective in about 50-70% of patients with major depressive disorder (MDD), they have a delayed onset of therapeutic effect. This latency is one of the current major limitations of these medications, in that it prolongs the impairments associated with depression, leaves patients vulnerable to an increased risk of suicide, increases the likelihood that a patient will prematurely discontinue therapy, and increases medical costs associated with severe depression. It is becoming increasingly clear that differences may exist between antidepressants and some evidence suggests that some antidepressant agents may begin to work faster than others. ⋯ Thus, current data do not clearly support claims that one drug reduces the symptoms of depression faster than another, though the existing literature suggests that escitalopram displays some superiority in terms of rapidity of action. Given the potential benefits of early-acting antidepressant treatments, the possibility of superior speed of onset of escitalopram presented here merits further study in adequately designed, prospective clinical trials. A definitive demonstration of early onset of action awaits the results of appropriately designed and powered clinical studies, which may include (1) a prospective definition of early onset of action, (2) more focused assessments of core emotional symptoms and cognitive deficits of depression by using specific and sensitive tools, (3) a data-analytic approach capable of capturing the dynamic nature of symptomatic change (for example, survival analysis), and (4) strategies to minimize biases and heterogeneity of response.
-
Frontotemporal dementia (FTD) is a neurological disorder characterised by the progressive degeneration of the frontal and anterior temporal cortex. FTD, as well as nonfluent progressive aphasia and semantic dementia, belongs to the more generic entity of frontotemporal lobe degeneration. Considering the involvement of the frontal lobe, the initial clinical presentation of FTD may be psychiatric, such as changes in personality or behavioural disorders. Psychiatrists, therefore, have to establish the differential diagnosis with late-onset schizophrenia or affective disorders. An accurate history of the onset of symptoms, thanks to the patient and especially to his/her family, is essential to recognize this dementia. In addition to behavioural changes, memory impairment, and speech disturbances are often present from the beginning. Consensus criteria have been proposed in 1998 that help to bring this diagnosis to mind in clinical practice. The progressive occurrence of personality changes or inappropriate social conducts in the fifth or sixth decade must prompt cognitive evaluation. NEUROCOGNITIVE AND BRAIN IMAGING DATA: A brief cognitive evaluation, such as the frontal assessment battery (FAB) may help to identify a dysexecutive syndrome and to prompt a thorough neuropsychological evaluation. The pattern of neuropsychological impairment reflects the involvement of the frontal lobe and appears different from that of other degenerative diseases, such as Alzheimer's dementia, which involves hippocampal damage. Additional investigations should however be made to detect a potentially curable dementia. Cerebral imaging is essential to the differential diagnosis and also shows evidence for the positive diagnosis of FTD. Structural MRI may initially not show the bilateral atrophy of the frontal lobe, but functional imaging may be helpful in the early stages of the illness by showing evidence of abnormalities in the anterior cerebral hemisphere. PATHOPHYSIOLOGICAL FINDINGS: In recent years, significant advances in the understanding of the pathological characteristics of FTD were made with genetic contribution, especially the discovery of the tau protein involvement. In fact, neuropathological examination with immunohistochemical analysis defines Pick's disease with Pick bodies that belong to tauopathies. Ubiquitinated intraneuronal inclusions may also be found, and some types of FTD have no distinctive pathological feature. However, although a definite diagnosis would only be established after postmortem pathological examination, the clinical, neuropsychological and imaging data enable the early identification of patients with FTD and, subsequently, the appropriate management. ⋯ Although the prevalence of FTD reaches 1 Alzheimer's disease (AD) to 1.6 FTD in the general population between 45- and 64-year old, only few studies have focused on the treatment of FTD. Some evidence supports the positive effect of serotonergic agents, especially with regard to behavioural symptoms. Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors or trazodone should therefore be prescribed in preference to acetylcholinesterase medications as in AD. However, no drug yet has the ability to stop or slow down the degenerative process. The management of daily life also bears specificities related to the younger age of these patients and to their behavioural disorders. Caregivers should receive some education about the characteristics of this dementia and should be helped in social management. As concerns aggressive behaviour, neuroleptics should generally be avoided because of poor tolerance. Finally, the outcome is characterized by a rapid loss of autonomy and sometimes by a premature institutionalisation.
-
Treatment of severe mental illness in the community is gaining interest under ethical, clinical and economical pressure, which has led to mental health reform and deinstitutionalisation. However, this can lead to conflicts between all the parties involved in the community. Several countries have initiated extensive efforts to coordinate health services to enhance quality of care without increasing costs. According to Gray [Hum Relat 38 (1985) 911-936.], the first conditions facilitating interorganizational collaboration are the identification of common problems, recognition of partners (legitimacy and expertise) and interest in collaborating gains to be made from such collaboration [int J Health Plann Manage 17(4) (2002) 315-32.]. ⋯ Deinstitutionalisation and more respect of patients' rights were considered as positive changes for most patients, but as a risk for the most vulnerable ones. Clearer mental health policy targets were requested for suicidal, difficult to engage and dual diagnosis patients. Collaborative efforts must focus on teaching primary care professionals for suicide and dual diagnosis patients, on direct help to welfare services for difficult to engage patients and on psychiatric services for high users. Intensive home care and liaison with primary care are viewed as key components. Identifying common targets in the network may enhance collaboration. Pathways to care need to be studied, including people involved outside a "classical" health network, such as police, welfare services and patients or carers associations.
-
While traumatic brain injury is a major public health issue, schizophrenia-like psychosis following traumatic brain injury is relatively rare and poorly studied. Yet the risk of developing schizophrenia-like psychosis after traumatic brain injury is 3 times more important than in the general population. ⋯ Further systematic studies are needed to confirm this hypothesis.