Archiwum medycyny sa̧dowej i kryminologii
-
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol · Jan 2007
[Permanent essential defacement--remarks on the possibilities of verification of the accepted criteria in medico-legal certification in criminal and civil law proceedings].
Despite the fact that some criteria of medico-legal certification in criminal and civil proceedings have been established, there are still some topics which are controversial and thus require modification. This is also true of the notion of "permanent essential defacement". ⋯ Additionally, the authors bring up for discussion the issue of experts taking into consideration the age and sex of the victims while assessing damages. A separate problem lies in difficulties in assessing the degree of detriment to health because of defacement due to the fact that official tables for evaluating permanent or long-term detriment to health do not include relevant information.
-
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol · Jan 2007
[Medico-legal opinions in cases for annulment of testament. Part I. Characteristics of investigative material. Characteristics of testators].
A very important issue in preparing medico-legal opinions is the establishment whether the devisor had the ability to bequeath at the date of preparing a testament. The subsequent loss of the ability of bequeathing does not have any impact on execution of the previously prepared testament. Experts who pass opinions in testament cases evaluate: 1) the testament itself and the circumstances of its preparation, excluding, however, the reliability of records, 2) statements obtained while interrogating witnesses (descriptions of daily life, motivation to bequeath), 3) medical records (files, case histories, discharge records). ⋯ The length of devisors survival following the drawing up of the final testament was generally short. In total, testaments not only in the oral form, but also made before a notary, were prepared by chronically ill individuals presenting with marked clinical symptoms, what was perceived by their family and caregivers as a sign of the imminent death. Hence, the testaments were often drawn up in a hospital room or in a notary office where the patient was taken between consecutive hospitalizations.
-
The objective of this work is a preliminary analysis of claims concerning nosocomial infections advanced by patients against public inpatient institutions. ⋯ 646 patient claims against medical institutions resulting from their civil liability were analyzed. All the claims included expert opinions issued by the Medical Department of PZU SA between the year 2003 and 2005. In the analyzed material, the majority of claims (85.3%) involved public hospitals. The value of the presented material is high, as PZU SA is practically the only insurance company that insures public hospitals against civil liability for medical procedures. Therefore, conclusions from the present analysis may be used to formulate certain generalized statements in the case of claims made by patients against public hospitals in Poland. Nosocomial infections constituted 32% of all patient claims against public hospitals. The majority of claims indicated Staphylococcus aureus infections (37%). Other common infections associated with patient claims were HBV and HCV infections, with HBV infections predominating at surgical and internal disease wards, while HCV infection claims were more common among gynecology and obstetrics patients. Staphylococcus aureus infections were dominant in orthopedic and traumatology wards. Some objective reasons may hinder formulation of an expert opinion, such as finding the causal association between the infection and the timing of hospitalization, or between the infection and the culpability of medical personnel. Medical opinions passed by doctors of the Medical Department in most cases remained ambiguous. New legal regulations that require obligatory reporting and registration of nosocomial infections provide a chance that some of these difficulties may be overcome in the near future.
-
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol · Oct 2006
Biography Historical Article[Sexual violence against women--the analysis of the phenomenon as exemplified by the Jack the Ripper case].
From the beginning of human civilization, sexuality has been controlled by morals and laws. Using the example of Jack the Ripper, the authors present the significant and very serious problem of violence against women in the aspect of crime detection and forensic sexuology. ⋯ Such crimes encompass sex murders. Criminal behaviors of a sexual nature are perpetrated by representatives of all social strata.
-
Arch Med Sadowej Kryminol · Oct 2006
[Double ritual murder by the Satanist cult members based on the casuistry of the Forensic Medicine Department in Katowice].
In recent years, an increased activity of various sects, especially Satanist ones, has been observed in Poland. This is associated with an increase in the number of various crimes, including offences against life and health. ⋯ In 1999, two cases of the murders of a 21-year-old woman and a 19-year-old man committed by Satanist cult members during their ritual mass were reported at the Forensic Medicine Department in Katowice. In the report, the authors present some issues associated with Satanism, the circumstances of these two murders and the results of medico-legal examinations of the victims.