• Richard H Kallet, Michael S Lipnick, and Gregory D Burns.
• Respiratory Care Division, Department of Anesthesia and Perioperative Care, University of California San Francisco at San Francisco General Hospital, San Francisco, California. richkallet@gmail.com.
• Respir Care. 2021 Mar 1; 66 (3): 510530510-530.

AbstractRecruitment maneuvers in ARDS are used to improve oxygenation and lung mechanics by applying high airway pressures to reopen collapsed or obstructed peripheral airways and alveoli. In the early 1990s, recruitment maneuvers became a central feature of a variant form of lung-protective ventilation known as open-lung ventilation. This strategy is based on the belief that repetitive opening and closing of distal airspaces induces shear injury and therefore contributes both to ventilator-induced lung injury and ARDS-associated mortality. However, the largest multi-center randomized controlled trial of open-lung ventilation in moderate to severe ARDS reported that recruitment maneuver plateau pressures of 50-60 cm H2O were associated with significantly higher mortality compared to traditional lung-protective ventilation. Despite being based on well conducted preclinical and clinical recruitment maneuver studies, the higher mortality associated with the open-lung ventilation strategy requires re-examining the assumptions and conclusions drawn from those previous studies. This narrative review examines the evidence used to design recruitment maneuver strategies. We also review the radiologic, rheologic, and histopathologic evidence regarding the nature of lung injury and the phenomena of recruitment and de-recruitment as it informs our perceptions of recruitment potential in ARDS. Major lung-protective ventilation clinical trial data and other clinical data are also examined to assess the practical necessity of recruitment maneuvers in ARDS and whether a subset of cases might benefit from pursuing recruitment maneuver therapy. Finally, a less a radical approach to recruitment maneuvers is offered that might achieve the goals of recruitment maneuvers with less risk of harm.Copyright © 2021 by Daedalus Enterprises.

15 keywords...

hide…