• Hubert Gagnon, Georges-Auguste Legault, Christian A Bellemare, Monelle Parent, Pierre Dagenais, Suzanne K-Bédard, Danielle Tapin, Louise Bernier, Jean-Pierre Béland, Charles-Étienne Daniel, and Johane Patenaude.
• Institut Interdisciplinaire d'Innovation Technologique (3IT) de l'Université de Sherbrooke, Parc Innovation P2, 3000 boulevard de l'Université Sherbrooke, Sherbrooke, QC, Canada, J1K 0A5.
• Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2020 Oct 28; 37: e9.

ObjectivesIntegration of ethics into technology assessment in healthcare (HTA) reports is directly linked to the need of decision makers to provide rational grounds justifying their social choices. In a decision-making paradigm, facts and values are intertwined and the social role of HTA reports is to provide relevant information to decision makers. Since 2003, numerous surveys and discussions have addressed different aspects of the integration of ethics into HTA. This study aims to clarify how HTA professionals consider the integration of ethics into HTA, so an international survey was conducted in 2018 and the results are reported here.MethodsA survey comprising twenty-two questions was designed and carried out from April 2018 to July 2018. Three hundred and twenty-eight HTA agencies from seventy-five countries were invited to participate in this survey.ResultsEighty-nine participants completed the survey, representing a participation rate of twenty-seven percent. As to how HTA reports should fulfill their social role, over 84 percent of respondents agreed upon the necessity to address this role for decision makers, patients, and citizens. At a lower level, the same was found regarding the necessity to make value-judgments explicit in different report sections, including ethical analysis. This contrasts with the response-variability obtained on the status of ethical analysis with the exception of the expertise required. Variability in stakeholder-participation usefulness was also observed.ConclusionsThis study reveals the importance of a three-phase approach, including assessment, contextual data, and recommendations, and highlights the necessity to make explicit value-judgments and have a systematic ethical analysis in order to fulfill HTA's social role in guiding decision makers.

13 keywords...

hide…