• Medical education · Nov 1999

    Brief problem-solving questions in medical school examinations: is it necessary for students to explain their answers?

    • P L Schwartz and E G Loten.
    • Department of Pathology, University of Otago Medical School, Dunedin, New Zealand.
    • Med Educ. 1999 Nov 1; 33 (11): 823-7.

    ObjectiveTo compare outcomes when answers to objective type problem-solving questions are marked with and without consideration of students' explanations of their answers.DesignStudents answered six multiple-part problem-solving questions on the final examination for a course in clinical biochemistry. Each part required a choice from a list, a number or a few words, plus an explanation or justification. Scores were determined independently for the answers alone and for the answers plus explanations. The outcomes of the two marking methods were compared.SettingDepartment of Pathology, University of Otago Medical School, Dunedin, New Zealand.SubjectsFinal year preclinical medical students.ResultsMarks were slightly higher for answers alone than for answers plus explanations (overall mean, 82.1%; standard deviation, 9.8% vs. 77.1%; 9.3%; P < 0.001 by paired t-test). There was a very high correlation between scores derived from the two methods (r=0. 87). Consideration of the answers alone (without explanations) was about as good as answers plus explanations in identifying students who performed at different levels overall on the examination and in identifying the weakest students.ConclusionsThe data suggest that when students arrived at the correct answers, their information and reasons were usually correct and that answers alone discriminate adequately among students with different levels of knowledge and ability. By dispensing with the requirement for explanations, we would be able to ask more questions and mark objectively, so competent students should not be disadvantaged by the lack of opportunity to explain their reasoning.

      Pubmed     Full text   Copy Citation     Plaintext  

      Add institutional full text...

    Notes

     
    Knowledge, pearl, summary or comment to share?
    300 characters remaining
    help        
    You can also include formatting, links, images and footnotes in your notes
    • Simple formatting can be added to notes, such as *italics*, _underline_ or **bold**.
    • Superscript can be denoted by <sup>text</sup> and subscript <sub>text</sub>.
    • Numbered or bulleted lists can be created using either numbered lines 1. 2. 3., hyphens - or asterisks *.
    • Links can be included with: [my link to pubmed](http://pubmed.com)
    • Images can be included with: ![alt text](https://bestmedicaljournal.com/study_graph.jpg "Image Title Text")
    • For footnotes use [^1](This is a footnote.) inline.
    • Or use an inline reference [^1] to refer to a longer footnote elseweher in the document [^1]: This is a long footnote..

    hide…

What will the 'Medical Journal of You' look like?

Start your free 21 day trial now.

We guarantee your privacy. Your email address will not be shared.