• Emily P Zeitler, Lauren G Gilstrap, Megan Coylewright, David J Slotwiner, Carrie H Colla, and Sana M Al-Khatib.
• Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center, 1 Medical Center Dr, Lebanon, NH 03756. Email: emily.p.zeitler@hitchcock.org.
• Am J Manag Care. 2022 Aug 1; 28 (8): 382389382-389.

ObjectivesCMS' coverage with evidence development (CED) policy allows Medicare beneficiaries to access promising therapies and services while additional data are collected. CED program characteristics are mostly unreported, and qualities associated with retirement of CED data collection requirements are unknown. We aimed to review and systematically describe CED program history and components and report programmatic elements correlated with retirement of CED data collection requirements, while identifying areas for policy improvement.Study DesignSystematic review.MethodsWe extracted CED information from the CMS website, ClinicalTrials.gov, PubMed, internet searches, and communication with CMS.ResultsThere were 27 CED determinations from 2005 to 2022 in 8 therapeutic areas, with the most for cardiovascular diseases (8/27; 30%). Duration of CED programs (range, 1-16 years) and the number of related registries and clinical trials (range, 0-34) were widely variable. Only 4 CEDs have had data collection requirements with continued National Coverage Determination (NCD); 3 relate to cardiovascular therapies, and all have some public availability of findings resulting from CED-related data collection mechanisms. There were 2 instances of NCD revocation and deferral to local coverage decisions.ConclusionsChanges in the CED program through improving program predictability and transparency with regard to outstanding questions, roles of relevant stakeholders, and requirements for reporting and reevaluation would strengthen the program's effectiveness. Ultimately, these improvements would provide incentives for stakeholder participation in data collection to achieve the goal of increasing access to beneficial therapies and improving clinical outcomes.

7 keywords...

hide…