• Tara Funk Corcoran, Remle Crowe, Christian Martin-Gill, and Sriram Ramgopal.
• Division of Emergency Medicine, Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children's Hospital of Chicago, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, Illinois.
• Prehosp Emerg Care. 2024 Jul 11: 181-8.

ObjectivesEmergency medical services (EMS) serves a critical role in the delivery of services to children with out-of-hospital emergencies. The EMS clinicians' initial field diagnoses, termed "impressions," facilitate focused patient assessments, guide the application of prehospital treatment protocols, and help determine transport destination. We sought to evaluate the concordance of the EMS clinician impression to a child's hospital-based diagnosis.MethodsWe retrospectively studied de-identified pediatric (<18 years old) scene runs transported to the hospital and with available linked hospital data from the 2021 ESO Data Collaborative, a multi-agency prehospital electronic health record dataset. EMS impressions and primary emergency department or admission-based diagnoses were categorized into one of twenty-one major groups in the Diagnosis Grouping System. We identified the most common hospital-based discharge diagnoses and evaluated for the agreement between EMS impression and hospital-based diagnosis using Cohen's Kappa statistic.ResultsWe included 35,833 pediatric transports from the scene with linked prehospital and in-hospital data (median age 11 years, interquartile range, 3-15 years; 50.9% male). The most common categories for both EMS impressions and hospital-based diagnoses were as follows respectively: trauma (26.1%; 24.6%), neurologic diseases (18.9%; 16.4%), psychiatric and behavioral diseases and substance use disorder (11.8%; 11.6%), and respiratory diseases (11.1% and 9.5%). A total of 23,224 out of 35,833 patients, or 64.8%, had concordant EMS impressions and hospital-based diagnoses. There was high agreement between common EMS impression and in-hospital diagnoses (trauma 77.3%; neurologic diseases 70.3%; respiratory diseases 64.5%; and psychiatric, behavioral disease and substance use disorder 73.9%). Hospital-based diagnoses demonstrated moderate concordance with prehospital data (Cohen's κ = 0.59).ConclusionsWe found moderate concordance between EMS primary impression and hospital diagnoses. The EMS encounter is brief and without capabilities of advanced testing, but initial impressions may influence the basis of the triage assignment and interventions during the hospital-based encounter. By evaluating EMS impressions and ultimate hospital diagnoses, pediatric protocols may be streamlined, and specific training emphasized in pursuit of improving patient outcomes. Future work is needed to examine instances of discordance and evaluate the impact on patient care and outcomes.

3 keywords...

hide…