• Fiona M Walter, A Toby Prevost, Joana Vasconcelos, Per N Hall, Nigel P Burrows, Helen C Morris, Ann Louise Kinmonth, and Jon D Emery.
• Department of Public Health & Primary Care, Strangeways Research Laboratory, Cambridge. fmw22@medschl.cam.ac.uk
• Br J Gen Pract. 2013 May 1; 63 (610): e345e353e345-53.

BackgroundGPs need to recognise significant pigmented skin lesions, given rising UK incidence rates for malignant melanoma. The 7-point checklist (7PCL) has been recommended by NICE (2005) for routine use in UK general practice to identify clinically significant lesions which require urgent referral.AimTo validate the Original and Weighted versions of the 7PCL in the primary care setting.Design And SettingDiagnostic validation study, using data from a SIAscopic diagnostic aid randomised controlled trial in eastern England.MethodAdults presenting in general practice with a pigmented skin lesion that could not be immediately diagnosed as benign were recruited into the trial. Reference standard diagnoses were histology or dermatology expert opinion; 7PCL scores were calculated blinded to the reference diagnosis. A case was defined as a clinically significant lesion for primary care referral to secondary care (total 1436 lesions: 225 cases, 1211 controls); or melanoma (36).ResultsFor diagnosing clinically significant lesions there was a difference between the performance of the Original and Weighted 7PCLs (respectively, area under curve: 0.66, 0.69, difference = 0.03, P<0.001). For the identification of melanoma, similar differences were found. Increasing the Weighted 7PCL's cut-off score from recommended 3 to 4 improved detection of clinically significant lesions in primary care: sensitivity 73.3%, specificity 57.1%, positive predictive value 24.1%, negative predictive value 92.0%, while maintaining high sensitivity of 91.7% and moderate specificity of 53.4% for melanoma.ConclusionThe Original and Weighted 7PCLs both performed well in a primary care setting to identify clinically significant lesions as well as melanoma. The Weighted 7PCL, with a revised cut-off score of 4 from 3, performs slightly better and could be applied in general practice to support the recognition of clinically significant lesions and therefore the early identification of melanoma.

21 keywords...

hide…