• Emerg Med Australas · Feb 2010

    Comparative Study

    Best Guess method: a further external validation study and comparison with other methods.

    • Julian Casey and Meredith Borland.
    • Emergency Department, Princess Margaret Hospital, Perth, Western Australia, Australia. juliancasey@iinet.net.au
    • Emerg Med Australas. 2010 Feb 1;22(1):68-74.

    ObjectiveValidation of the 'Best Guess' weight estimation method on a geographically divergent external sample of children, plus comparison with APLS and Broselow weight estimation methods.MethodsProspective cross-sectional analytical study at Princess Margaret Hospital Emergency Department. A convenience sample of children aged 0-14 years recruited from May to June 2008. Age, sex, ethnicity, height and actual weight obtained. Agreement between the methods is reported as a comparative mean and distribution of the percentage error, plus the proportion of instances where the error exceeded 20% of the measured weight.ResultsA total of 1235 children were included. The 'Best Guess' method was the most accurate, particularly in children aged 1-4 years (mean percentage error +1.69%). In other age groups it overestimated weight, with mean percentage errors ranging from 3.41% to 6.25%. Across all age groups the Broselow method was most precise, with tendency to underestimate weight across age groups with mean percentage errors ranging from -5.28% to -7.24%. The APLS method was least accurate and precise, with mean percentage errors ranging from -12.61% to -17.36%. Net weight underestimation errors exceeding 20% were associated with increased mean body mass index.ConclusionThe Best Guess weight estimation method is accurate, especially in children aged 1-4 years. It moderately overestimates weight in other ages. The Broselow method was more precise, whereas the APLS method was the least accurate and precise of all. The ease of use of the Broselow method argues for greater use in the ED and prehospital setting.

      Pubmed     Full text   Copy Citation     Plaintext  

      Add institutional full text...

    Notes

     
    Knowledge, pearl, summary or comment to share?
    300 characters remaining
    help        

    hide…

What will the 'Medical Journal of You' look like?

Start your free 21 day trial now.

We guarantee your privacy. Your email address will not be shared.