Social science & medicine
-
Social science & medicine · Sep 2003
ORS is never enough: physician rationales for altering standard treatment guidelines when managing childhood diarrhoea in Thailand.
This study explores Thai physicians' rationales about their prescribing practices for treating childhood diarrhoea within the public hospital system in central Thailand. Presented first are findings of a prospective clinical audit and observations of 424 cases treated by 38 physicians used to estimate the prevalence of sub-optimal prescribing practices according to Thai government and WHO treatment guidelines. ⋯ The rationales offered by Thai physicians for adhering or not adhering to standard treatment guidelines for childhood diarrhoea are contextualised in the light of current clinical, ethical and philosophical debates about evidence-based guidelines. We argue that differing views about clinical autonomy, definitions of optimal care and optimal efficiency, and tensions between patient-oriented and community-wide health objectives determine how standard practice guidelines for childhood diarrhoea in Thailand are implemented.
-
Social science & medicine · Sep 2003
'Taking public health out of the ghetto': the policy and practice of multi-disciplinary public health in the United Kingdom.
Until recently, a medical qualification was required for senior public health posts in the UK National Health Service. Since 1997, the new Labour government has expressed its intention to take public health 'out of the ghetto' and to develop multi-disciplinary public health. In particular, it has announced the creation of a new senior professional role of specialist in public health equivalent to the consultant in public health medicine, and open to a range of disciplines. ⋯ Professions are part of the process of governmentality, and their autonomy is always contingent upon the wider political context. Thus public health doctors have not abandoned the professional project; they have simply accepted the political reality that the boundaries need to shift rapidly from a politically unsustainable medical/non-medical distinction to one between those with and without expert knowledge. The concept of manipulated emergence helps explain why, having expressed a commitment towards multi-disciplinary public health, the government has not supported its policy more fully.