Journal of health services research & policy
-
The world class commissioning (WCC) programme was introduced in the English NHS in 2007 to develop primary care trust (PCT) commissioning of health services. There has been limited evaluation of health commissioning initiatives over the years and in particular little is known about how commissioners interpret and implement initiatives and guidance intended to strengthen commissioning. This research explores the development and implementation of WCC and draws implications for future commissioning arrangements. ⋯ The findings have implications for emerging clinical commissioning groups (CCGs) in the English NHS. Specifically, the research highlights the need for a system-wide approach to improving commissioning, including appropriately aligned policy and objectives underpinned by a co-ordinated and supportive organizational culture.
-
J Health Serv Res Policy · Jan 2012
Effects of the Blair/Brown NHS reforms on socioeconomic equity in health care.
The central objectives of the 'Blair/Brown' reforms of the English NHS in the 2000s were to reduce hospital waiting times and improve the quality of care. However, critics raised concerns that the choice and competition elements of reform might undermine socioeconomic equity in health care. By contrast, the architects of reform predicted that accelerated growth in NHS spending combined with increased patient choice of hospital would enhance equity for poorer patients. ⋯ Study three found that potential incentives for public hospitals to select against socioeconomically-disadvantaged hip replacement patients were small, compared with incentives to select against elderly and co-morbid patients. Taken together, these findings suggest that the Blair/Brown reforms had little effect on socioeconomic equity in health care. This may be because the 'dose' of competition was small and most hospital services continued to be provided by public hospitals which did not face strong incentives to select against socioeconomically-disadvantaged patients.
-
J Health Serv Res Policy · Jan 2012
Commissioning processes in primary care trusts: a repeated cross-sectional survey of health care commissioners in England.
To determine the extent to which primary care trusts (PCTs) in England employed processes associated with quality commissioning and to assess whether changes occurred in these processes during a policy drive to improve commissioning. ⋯ PCT commissioners reported clinical engagement in the majority of commissioning initiatives, a shift towards partnership commissioning, and increased involvement of patients and public in the development of initiatives. The new model of commissioning in England through clinical commissioning groups will need to improve on these processes if it is to demonstrate a higher quality approach to commissioning.
-
J Health Serv Res Policy · Jan 2012
Provider diversity in the English NHS: a study of recent developments in four local health economies.
To assess the impact of provider diversity on quality and innovation in the English NHS by mapping the extent of diverse provider activity and identifying the differences in performance between Third Sector Organisations (TSOs), for-profit private enterprises, and incumbent organizations within the NHS, and the factors that affect the entry and growth of new providers. ⋯ There is scope to increase the participation of diverse providers in the NHS but care must be taken not to damage public accountability, overall productivity, equity and NHS providers (especially acute hospitals, which are likely to remain in the NHS) in the process.
-
To analyse how competition is experienced and characterized by NHS and independent sector acute care providers in the English National Health Service (NHS). ⋯ The providers' view of the market and the relevance of historical relationships and loyalties suggest fine grained variations in competition which is consistent with a relational rather than structural approach to competition. Also the evidence on embeddedness of relationships implies that collaboration might be a strong lever for quality improvement locally. Finally, some of the agreements found might be deemed in breach of the rules of competition but they may well be in the interests of patients and taxpayers, with implications for regulation in publicly funded health care systems.