Revue de chirurgie orthopédique et réparatrice de l'appareil moteur
-
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot · Oct 2008
Multicenter Study Comparative Study Clinical Trial[Femoral neck fractures in patients over 50 years old].
Despite many papers and instructional course lectures, therapeutic guidelines are not clearly defined about treatment of femoral neck fractures. The aim of this multicentric French symposium was to prospectively study the results of current therapeutic options in order to propose scientifically proven options. ⋯ For young patients, ORIF should be the treatment of choice: the initial displacement and its effects on the femoral head vascularisation, the quality of reduction and fixation are the two most significant factors for good outcome. For Garden 1, fractures in patients 65 years old or more, it is proposed to performed an internal fixation despite in two thirds of the cases, it should be unnecessary because non identification of predictive factors of failure. For patients over 65 years old, the type of arthroplasty to perform in displaced fractures is to be chosen according to the preoperative mobility and comorbidities. Because of acetabular erosion with long-term follow-up, it is clearly indicated to perform total hip replacement for patients with life expectancy of 10 years or more. For frail patients, unipolar arthroplasty is the best option. The place for bipolar or uncemented implants is not yet well-defined and more prospective trials are needed. In this multicentric study, results appear quite different in terms of mortality, or functional status. These differences seem to be related to technical choice, geriatric care, nutritional consideration or surgical organisation, all factors that may be of major importance for prognostic.
-
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot · Oct 2008
Comparative Study[Distal femoral torsion: comparison of CT scan and intra operative navigation measurements during total knee arthroplasty. A report of 70 cases].
Proper positioning of the prosthesis components in total knee arthroplasty is an important factor for satisfactory outcomes such as mobility, pain and wear. If an independent cutting technique is performed, rotational alignment of the femoral component should adapt patient's specific anatomy. The distal epiphyseal femoral torsion (DEFT) is adjusted in order to align the prosthetic posterior condylar axis along the bone transepicondylar axis. The DEFT presents a high rate of interindividual variations. Computed tomography scanning produces reliable and reproducible measurement of the epiphyseal torsion, but this requires additional procedure. We therefore used intraoperative computed navigation for DEFT measurement, thus accurately adapting each patient's epiphyseal torsion during the procedure, without resorting to the preoperative CT scan. ⋯ Our results report a large variability in distal epiphyseal femoral torsion measured with CT scan. Moreover, computed navigation does not provide a reliable and reproducible evaluation of the epiphyseal torsion. Due to inaccurate identification of femoral epicondyles, the related navigated measurement is not considered to be reliable and reproducible. Navigated HKA at 90 degrees of knee flexion is not a fair indirect reflection of epiphyseal torsion. Computer-assisted navigation fails to provide direct or indirect, reliable and reproducible intraoperative measurement of distal epiphyseal femoral torsion. Preoperative CT scan is the only reliable method to produce accurate measurement of distal epiphyseal femoral torsion.
-
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot · Oct 2008
[Total knee arthroplasty with bicruciate preservation: Comparison versus the same posterostabilized design at eight years follow-up].
The purpose of this study was to determine the functional, clinical and radiographic results obtained with total knee arthroplasty (TKA) preserving both cruciate ligaments using the Hermès prosthesis with a fixed plateau. Mid-term results at eight years mean follow-up were compared with the outcome achieved at the same follow-up with posterior-stabilized (PS) Hermès TKA with a fixed bearing. ⋯ The risk of prosthetic loosening is not greater with TKA bicruciate sparing designs than with PS knees when the postoperative frontal laxity and the frontal realignment are satisfactory. They enabled better function but greater operative precision is required to achieve pain-free knees with a good range of motion.
-
Rev Chir Orthop Reparatrice Appar Mot · Oct 2008
[Rotational alignment of femoral component with computed-assisted surgery (CAS) during total knee arthroplasty].
Accurate implantation of the prosthesis components is a prognostic factor for long-term total knee arthroplasty survival as it reduces wear and loosening failure. Computer-assisted navigation systems have proved to produce accurate bone cuts orthogonal to the mechanical axis. Proper rotational alignment of the femoral component is one of the requirements for optimal positioning of the femoral prosthesis. The posterior bicondylar axis of the femoral prosthesis should therefore be parallel to the transepicondylar axis. The purpose of the present study was to determine whether computer-assisted navigation provides an accurate rotational alignment of the femoral implant, when preoperatively defined with CT scan. ⋯ When femoral and tibial bone cuts are performed independently, conventional instrumentation techniques seem insufficient to adapt patient's specific anatomy and prove inadequate to provide precise rotational alignment of the femoral component. Computed tomography scan is a reliable mean to produce precise preoperative measurements for proper DEFT. Moreover, it allows accurate postoperative control of the implant positioning. Other studies have documented a higher degree of precision in the rotational alignment of the femoral component with computed navigation systems in comparison to conventional instrumentation. However, in such studies, rotational alignment was always determined by computer navigation, and based on a controversial intraoperative identification (epicondyles and Whiteside's line referencing). We believe that preoperative CT scanning is a more favourable method. Actually, 77% of the cases reported satisfactory rotational alignment of the femoral component using this technique.