The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society
-
Randomized Controlled Trial
The endogenous opioid system is not involved in modulation of opioid-induced hyperalgesia.
Some recent studies suggested a role of the endogenous opioid system in modulating opioid-induced hyperalgesia (OIH). In order to test this hypothesis, we conducted a prospective randomized, placebo-controlled, 2-way crossover study in healthy human volunteers. We utilized a well-established model of inducing OIH after a brief exposure to the μ-opioid agonist remifentanil using intradermal electrical stimulation. Patients were exposed to a randomized 90-minute infusion of remifentanil or saline placebo during 2 separate occasions. Development of OIH was quantified using changes in the average radius of the area of secondary hyperalgesia generated by electrical pain stimulation. A 23.6% (20.2) increase in area of secondary hyperalgesia over baseline was observed in the postinfusion period of the remifentanil session, demonstrating development of OIH (P = .03). In order to test endogenous opioid system modulation of OIH, patients were given a 1-time bolus of naloxone, which had no effect on the size of the hyperalgesic lesion in either the remifentinal or placebo session. These results suggested that the endogenous opioid system did not appear to modulate OIH. ⋯ Experimental evidence suggested that the endogenous opioid system did not significantly affect opioid-induced hyperalgesia. Consequently, this study suggested that alternative mechanisms such as pronociceptive stimulation and neuroplastic changes might be responsible for expression of OIH.
-
Chronic pain after spinal cord injury represents a therapeutic challenge. Progesterone, a neuroprotective steroid, has been shown to modulate nociceptive thresholds, whereas its effect on neuropathic pain needs to be further explored. In this study, we evaluated whether progesterone could ameliorate pain-associated behaviors in animals subjected to a spinal cord hemisection. The development of mechanical and cold allodynia was assessed in injured male rats treated with daily injections of progesterone or vehicle. The expression of N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor (NMDAR) subunits, protein kinase C gamma (PKCγ), preprodynorphin (ppD), and kappa opioid receptor (KOR), key players in chronic pain mechanisms, was determined in the dorsal spinal cord. Twenty-eight days after injury, all vehicle-treated animals presented allodynic behaviors and a marked increase in NMDAR subunits, PKCγ, and ppD mRNA levels, with no changes in KOR mRNA levels. Progesterone prevented the development of mechanical allodynia and reduced the painful responses to cold stimulation. In correlation with the attenuation of pain behaviors, the steroid prevented NMDAR subunits and PKCγ mRNAs upregulation, did not modify the elevated ppD mRNA levels, but increased KOR expression. In conclusion, progesterone modulates neuropathic pain after spinal cord injury, creating a favorable molecular environment that may decrease spinal nociceptive signaling. ⋯ The present study suggests that progesterone administration could represent an interesting strategy to modulate neuropathic pain circuits after spinal cord injury. Further studies are needed to investigate the potential progesterone receptors involved in these actions.
-
Quantitative sensory testing (QST) has become commonly used for the assessment of pain in subjects with clinical conditions. However, there is no consensus about which type of QST is the best predictor of clinical pain responses. The purposes of this study were to determine: a) the QST measure with the strongest association with clinical pain intensity; and b) if the QST measure continued to predict clinical pain intensity in a model including relevant psychological factors. Fifty-nine patients seeking treatment for shoulder pain underwent experimental pain assessment involving heat and pressure stimuli. The patients also completed validated questionnaires for pain intensity, pain catastrophizing, anxiety, and depression. The 5th pain rating in a series of suprathreshold heat pain stimuli accounted for a significant amount of variance in clinical pain intensity, with no other QST measure contributing to the model. The 5th pain rating remained a significant contributor to clinical pain intensity when psychological factors were included in the model. Furthermore, subjects with elevated 5th pain rating, pain catastrophizing, and depression scores had higher clinical pain intensity ratings in pre- and postoperative assessments. These data suggest that assessment of pain should include suprathreshold heat stimuli and psychological factors separately, and a combination of these factors may be predictive of pain intensity outcomes. ⋯ The current study provides evidence for a suprathreshold heat pain response as a clinically relevant QST measure for patients with shoulder pain, even after psychological factors were considered. The present findings suggest that the 5th pain rating from a series of suprathreshold stimuli, pain catastrophizing, and depression might play a role in predicting pain intensity outcomes.
-
The reports on pain perception among former heroin addicts receiving methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) vary with regard to pain and intolerance threshold, and perception of suprathreshold stimuli has not been previously evaluated. Our aim was to systematically assess perception of threshold and suprathreshold noxious and innocuous stimuli with special attention to the effect of MMT dose and the presence of chronic pain. Noxious and innocuous, thermal and mechanical thresholds and ratings of suprathreshold heat-pain stimuli were measured among 31 MMT subjects receiving high and low MMT dose, with and without chronic pain, and in 17 healthy controls. The characteristics of chronic pain were also evaluated. MMT dose and chronic pain differentially affected pain perception. Whereas MMT dose did not affect thresholds, chronic pain MMT subjects exhibited increased pain threshold and pain-free MMT subjects exhibited decreased pain threshold compared with controls. MMT in general was associated with decreased perception of suprathreshold pain; however, MMT subjects with chronic pain exhibited increased suprathreshold pain ratings. It appears that subjects receiving MMT are hyperalgesic but that chronic pain in these subjects interferes with threshold measurements, inducing an apparent hypoalgesia. On the other hand, chronic pain reduces the analgesic effect of methadone seen in pain-free MMT subjects, amplifying suprathreshold pain perception. Factors such as chronic pain and MMT dose should be taken into account in future studies on pain perception in this population. ⋯ We show that the presence of chronic pain and methadone dose significantly affects perception of pain in former heroin addicts receiving MMT. Studying the alteration in pain perception in these subjects may contribute to understanding the high rates of chronic pain among them and may promote better treatment.
-
We evaluated the effectiveness of intrathecal antagonists of α1- (WB4101) and α2- (idazoxan) adrenoceptors and serotonergic (methysergide), opioid (naloxone), muscarinic (atropine), GABA(A) (bicuculline) and GABA(B) (phaclofen) receptors in blocking 2- or 100-Hz electroacupuncture (EA)-induced analgesia (EAIA) in the rat tail-flick test. EA was applied bilaterally to the Zusanli and Sanyinjiao acupoints in lightly anesthetized rats. EA increased tail-flick latency, where the effect of 2-Hz EA lasted longer than that produced by 100-Hz EA. The 2-Hz EAIA was inhibited by naloxone or atropine, was less intense and shorter after WB4101 or idazoxan, and was shorter after methysergide, bicuculline, or phaclofen. The 100-Hz EAIA was less intense and shorter after naloxone and atropine, less intense and longer after phaclofen, shorter after methysergide or bicuculline, and remained unchanged after WB4101 or idazoxan. We postulate that the intensity of the effect of 2-Hz EA depends on noradrenergic descending mechanisms and involves spinal opioid and muscarinic mechanisms, whereas the duration of the effect depends on both noradrenergic and serotonergic descending mechanisms, and involves spinal GABAergic modulation. In contrast, the intensity of 100-Hz EAIA involves spinal muscarinic, opioid, and GABA(B) mechanisms, while the duration of the effects depends on spinal serotonergic, muscarinic, opioid, and GABA(A) mechanisms. ⋯ The results of this study indicate that 2- and 100-Hz EA induce analgesia in the rat tail-flick test activating different descending mechanisms at the spinal cord level that control the intensity and duration of the effect. The adequate pharmacological manipulation of such mechanisms may improve EA effectiveness for pain management.